Medicate or Meditate?

Evaluating the importance of chronic pain acceptance amid the opioid epidemic.

Author | Anna Kratz

The opioid epidemic has left us scrambling for solutions that simultaneously address the need to manage chronic pain and solve the problems of opioid addiction and overdose that have plagued the nation. In the process of formulating a solution, many have reflected on what led us to this point. While some have rightly highlighted the role of marketing practices of opioid manufacturers as critical in the making of this epidemic, a number of broader cultural factors also bear responsibility.

In the late 1990s, there began a national push to evaluate pain as a fifth vital sign and treat it with commensurate seriousness. This effectively reinforced a pre-existing dominant American notion that pain is a problem that must be solved. In contrast, some cultural traditions hold that pain is natural and expected, and need not prevent one from living a meaningful life.

Interestingly, around the same time as the emergence of pain as a fifth vital sign, the concept of chronic pain acceptance began to gain traction in the field of pain psychology. Pain acceptance reflects the attitude that pain, while not preferable, is OK, and that even chronic pain does not inevitably prevent a person from getting on with what they value in life. The thinking here is that pain acceptance can provide a sort of pressure-release valve that relinquishes people from the often constant struggle to achieve pain relief. In the context of chronic pain, experiencing occasional breaks during which pain is sometimes allowed rather than resisted can create mental and emotional space. In this space, the person can think about what else they want from life, besides pain relief.

In the late 1990s, there began a national push to evaluate pain as a fifth vital sign and treat it with commensurate seriousness. This effectively reinforced a pre-existing dominant American notion that pain is a problem that must be solved.

Across many studies in various clinical populations, pain acceptance has been shown to be related to better outcomes, including lower emotional distress and better functional outcomes, for people with chronic pain. What prior research does not speak to is how pain acceptance relates to the use of other types of pain management strategies, such as medication use. I recently led a study that examined how pain acceptance is related to the use of both opioid and non-opioid pain medications. This study, published in The Clinical Journal of Pain, was conducted with people who have chronic pain secondary to spinal cord injury, a condition in which side effects from pain medications, even non-narcotic medications, can be quite dangerous.

We found that those with higher pain acceptance reported significantly lower use of all types of pain medications; every one-unit increase on the pain acceptance scale corresponded with 3% lower odds of opioid use. The association between pain medication usage and pain acceptance was significant, above and beyond the effects of the level of depressive symptoms, pain intensity, and pain distribution.

The data supported our idea that those who were more accepting of pain relied less on pain medications, and that this association was independent of the effects of mood, as well as the intensity and distribution of pain. These findings suggest that pain acceptance has a role to play in helping individuals reduce reliance on opioid medications and indicate a way forward for our collective attitude toward pain. Retaining the emphasis in medicine of evaluating pain as a "vital sign" need not be abandoned. Indeed, I would advocate for greater communication about pain in an effort to collaboratively develop more individualized and multi-modal pain treatment strategies.

We found that those with higher pain acceptance reported significantly lower use of all types of pain medications; every one-unit increase on the pain acceptance scale corresponded with 3% lower odds of opioid use.

It bears mentioning that people with chronic pain often feel upset when they hear pain professionals talk about acceptance of chronic pain. It's admittedly easy to hear "resignation" in the word acceptance, as if we are asking people to give up on the hope that we will find more pain relief than they have now. Patients may feel it's a way to relinquish our professional responsibility to help them manage their pain.

As someone who has lived with chronic pain for over a decade, I get it. But I also understand that my pain is not likely to ever go away completely, so accepting this reality is going to be necessary if I want to avoid a pain-focused life. Although the title of this article implies an either/or approach, pain acceptance will likely result in the greatest benefit for people with chronic pain when used in concert with other approaches, which may include medications.

People who are higher in pain acceptance may feel less of a need to relieve all pain, use a broader and more flexible repertoire of coping strategies, and rely less on pain medications as a result. Pain acceptance can be increased through psychological treatments, including cognitive behavioral therapy, acceptance and commitment therapy, and mindfulness-based stress reduction. Future studies that examine the effects of these behavioral treatments, and the role of pain acceptance in avoiding initiation of opioid medication and tapering from opioids, are warranted. The opioid epidemic is a complex puzzle, and this approach could be an important piece of the solution.

Anna Kratz, Ph.D., is an associate professor of physical medicine and rehabilitation. The study she references appears in the April 2018 issue of The Clinical Journal of Pain.


More Articles About: gray matters Opioids Pain pain acceptance Overdose Epidemic opinion
Featured News & Stories
Medicine at Michigan
Medicate or Meditate?
Evaluating chronic pain acceptance amid the opioid epidemic
man woman holding brown small dogs christmas photo smiling neutral color sweaters grey biege
Health Lab
Young man’s debilitating back pain a thing of the past
Piotrowski consulted with a spectrum of doctors, physical therapists and chiropractors, each with a different recommendation for how to treat a herniated disc in the lower portion of his spine until he found one at Michigan Medicine recommending lumbar microdiscectomy, a procedure that involves small incisions to remove portions of the herniated disc and ease pressure on the spinal cord nerves.
woman in hospital on left in ICU and the other right side woman standing in jean jacket and black clothes smiling
Health Lab
Brain tumor and car crash survivor aspires to be example for others living with disabilities
A car accident at age 20 left Sahar Mashhour in the intensive care unit for three months. Almost six years later, Mashhour is still pursuing her passions proving that her disability doesn’t limit her ability, but instead helps her see life through a different lens.
Health Lab
Managing scleroderma symptoms through a team approach
Research published in the Arthritis Care and Research Journal from Michigan Medicine found that scleroderma patients made significant strides when working with trained peer health coaches in adhering to wellness routines, leading to resilience and improvements in fatigue, pain and depressive symptoms.
Michigan Medicine neuroscientist Huda Akil, Ph.D., accepts National Medal of Science from President Joe Biden.
News Release
U-M neuroscientist Huda Akil, Ph.D., wins National Medal of Science
Distinguished U-M neuroscientist Huda Akil, Ph.D., has received the nation’s highest scientific honor – the National Medal of Science -- for her contributions to science and their impact on humankind’s understanding of depression, anxiety, addiction and more.
script on rx
Health Lab
Opioid limits didn’t change surgery patients’ experience, study shows
Surgical opioid prescription limits reduced the number of narcotic pills patients received after their operations, but didn’t lead to worse pain scores or less satisfaction.